Bates leaves opposition crying foul

Financial Times

Roger Blitz, Leisure Industries Correspondent

Ken Bates invoked Iraq’s executed former dictator to justify his continued stewardship of Leeds United football club.

“Ninety-nine per cent of the letters and e-mails are supporting us,” the club’s chairman said this week as he sought to buy back the club from administration. “That’s as good as Saddam Hussein did and he was fiddling the figures.”

Mr Bates, who sold Chelsea to Roman Abramovich, is this weekend banking on his famed determination and cussedness to hold on to the Elland Road club.

Opposing him to varying degrees are local MPs, Leeds supporters, the Football League and HM Revenue & Customs.

Mr Bates, 75, who first took control of the club in January 2005, has presided over the latest decline in a once mighty club that as recently as 2001 were semi-finalists of the Champions League. Yet his opponents have thus far proved powerless to unseat him.

The club’s most startling decline came under former chairman Peter Ridsdale, who borrowed heavily in the expectation of future revenues from further years of Champions League qualification. The club missed out on qualification, triggering one of the more rapid and pitiful collapses in British sport.

The sale of players reduced debts to about £21m when Mr Bates bought the club from Leeds chartered accountant Gerald Krasner.

Last year, it was one match away from a return to the Premier League. But in May, Mr Bates took Leeds into administration with debts of £35m and the team were relegated into League One, the third tier of the English football pyramid.

KPMG, its administrators, this week said it was fast running out of cash and heading for liquidation.

But Mr Bates continues to outwit his enemies. He proposed buying back the club, offering creditors 1p in the pound, and won a Company Voluntary Arrangement from creditors by a narrow margin last month.

Revenue & Customs, owed £7.7m by the club, challenged the vote, despite Mr Bates upping his offer to them. It issued a 52-pagewitness statement questioning the voting rights of threeoffshore creditors, Krator Trust, Astor Investment Holdings and Forward Sports Fund, who represent 45 per cent of creditors.

The statement alleged these creditors were linked to Mr Bates.

In stepped KPMG, forestalling Revenue & Customs’ challenge in the High Court by putting the club up for sale again at 8pm last Friday and inviting bids by Monday. Bidders had six hours to examine Leeds’ accounts and four bids were lodged.

On Wednesday, KPMG announced Mr Bates had won the bid with an undisclosed sum.

Mr Bates is thought to have bid around 13p in the pound. A consortium of Redbus, the investment company headed by Simon Franks, and Simon Morris, a local property developer, is understood to have offered 30p. So too, it appears, did Adam Pearson, the club’s former commercial director.

The identity of the fourth bidder has not been disclosed.

So why did Mr Bates win? Astor, the largest of the creditors, told KPMG that it would waive its debts only if Mr Bates won the auction. Victory for Mr Bates.

Colin Burgon, a Leeds MP, said the Leeds United case raises issues about football governance.

“Many of us now are looking seriously at the role of companies registered abroad but having a decisive role in football clubs in Britain,” he said.

The Football League, under the chairmanship of former Conservative minister Lord Mawhinney, isfurious. Now it is refusing to hand over the so-called “golden” share all clubs need to enable them to play in the league.

Appalled at the way KPMG has handled the administration, particularly the sale of the club without a CVA, the league is threatening court action and demanding greater transparency from the club and the accountancy company.

KPMG’s view is that it had to act in haste because ofthe parlous state of theclub and that it wouldbe impossible to achieve another CVA because of Astor’s position.

Leeds MPs also want an explanation from KPMG as to why they said Astor was registered in Guernsey when it is in fact based in theBritish Virgin Islands.

What puzzles them further is why Yorkshire Radio, owned by Mr Bates, is owed £470,000 by the club.

The club called on the league to transfer the golden share “to bring all matters to a satisfactory conclusion and allow the club to concentrate on football again”.

But Mr Bates’ enemies are joining forces, hoping to prevent his regime at Leeds from continuing much longer.

League refuses to approve Leeds sale

Financial Times

Roger Blitz, Leisure Industries Correspondent

The Football League is refusing to sanction the sale of Leeds United to Ken Bates, the club’s chairman, and has launched an inquiry into the handling of the club’s affairs by its administrator, KPMG.

In a hard-hitting statement released on its website on Thursday, the league said it had failed to receive the required documentation and assurances from KPMG over its intended sale of the club to Mr Bates.

“To date, no documentation regarding the sale has been submitted to the league by the administrators,” the league said.

KPMG on Wednesday resold the club to Mr Bates for an undisclosed sum without a company voluntary arrangement. It solicited bids for the club last Friday after the Inland Revenue challenged a creditors’ deal put together by Mr Bates last month.

The deadline for bids expired on Monday, and Mr Bates’ bid trumped a joint offer from Simon Franks of investment company Redbus, and property developer Simon Morris.

Mr Bates, who took over the club in January 2005, took the club into administration in May, with debts of £35m.

KPMG said on Wednesday it knew the league would not consider transferring its football share, which effectively registers the club with the league, to a new entity without a CVA.

In its statement, the league said that without the required documentation and assurances it was unable to transfer Leeds’ share in the league to the club. It also demanded certainty from KPMG on the Inland Revenue’s legal proceedings against the administrator.

However, the league said there was nothing in its regulations to stop the club playing in the league while under administration. The new season, with Leeds scheduled to play in League One, begins next month.

A meeting of the board on Thursday morning concluded it was concerned at the handling of the whole process by KPMG “and the chairman was instructed to obtain legal advice in that regard”.

It added that KPMG had asked to attend the board meeting, and the league had expected it to be there. “The league was informed late yesterday afternoon that they would not be attending, with no explanation provided,” the league’s statement said.

KPMG were unable to offer immediate comment on the situation.

Bates fights off £36.5m rival bid to regain control of Leeds

The Times

Rick Broadbent

Ken Bates declared victory in the battle for Leeds United last night after fending off a £36.5 million rival bid and resuming control of the Coca-Cola League One club. The chairman rounded on his rivals after KPMG, the administrator, sold the club to him, but he still needs to convince the Football League and Revenue & Customs that the deal is right.

As officials meet today to decide whether to return the club’s Football League share ? a requirement if Leeds are to be allowed to compete next season ? the size of one of the failed bids will intrigue fans. Sources revealed that the deal put together by Simon Franks, the Redbus founder, and Simon Morris, the property tycoon, was worth £16.5 million, with a further £20 million to be invested on players over 2½ years. Franks said that he was “gobsmacked” at the outcome.

Bates said that Franks had “never been to Leeds”, before targeting his other rivals. “We have serious investors who want to come in for the right reasons,” Bates said. “Simon Morris was more interested in the property than the football club.”

Franks said: “I think we provided proof of funds of £10 million against his [Bates’s] £350,000 ? and we still lost by the vagaries of the process.” Franks claimed that only Bates had been allowed to see the books.

Another challenge is possible, but Bates’s first task is to convince the Football League that all football debts will be settled.

Bates’ rival enters Leeds fray and pledges to restore former glories

The Guardian

Matt Scott (Guardian News)

Ken Bates has been accused of “playing with the emotions” of Leeds United fans with his claims this week that the club could collapse as a result of the taxman’s challenge to his takeover.

HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) lodged its formal opposition to the Bates consortium’s takeover on Tuesday, with a preliminary court hearing set for tomorrow. A meeting was held yesterday involving the Football League and the administrator, KPMG, and there was another summit involving KPMG, HMRC and club directors as Bates sought to rescue his consortium’s ownership of the club.

It is believed that the consortium is willing to improve on its 8p-in-the-pound offer, which the taxman had rejected on Tuesday. But in the meantime rival bidders were joining the fray.

Simon Franks, of the Redbus Group, a corporate fund that specialises in turning around ailing companies, yesterday declared his firm’s interest.

“We have put in an offer of considerably more than the 8p bid by Bates,” said Franks. “We are the only UK group bidding for Leeds for its football abilities. Unlike other bidders’, ours is not a property deal. We believe that Leeds is a top-10 team and its rightful place is in the Premiership.”

Franks’s group has £35m at its disposal and, after paying off creditors the sums required to take control of the club from the administrators, would commit the remainder to player wages and transfer fees rather than to the buyback of the freeholds at Elland Road and the Thorp Arch training ground.

“With a tweak of the way the club is run we can get Leeds back to its former glory,” said Franks. “Our interests are utterly aligned with those of the fans.

“Leeds will survive, whatever happens here. Bates is trying to protect his interests but it’s an unfair tactic to say it faces liquidation. He shouldn’t play with the emotions of the fans.”

While the club remains in administration there is an embargo on player trading. That has made life difficult but although the chairman, Bates, had stated on Tuesday that his club would go to the wall if his takeover failed, there were more conciliatory noises yesterday from Elland Road. That was in response to concerns among club supporters that their funds paid for season-ticket renewals were at risk.

In a statement Leeds said: “We understand it is a worry for supporters who have invested in the club for next season, but you can be assured it is in everyone’s collective interest for the club to continue. This is what we are working to achieve.”

Lovefilm and Video Island link up

BBC News Online

BBC News Online

Online DVD rental firms Lovefilm and Video Island, the largest two such providers in the UK, are to merge.

The firms will join under the Lovefilm brand, with the equal merger giving them greater scale to compete against US rivals Blockbuster and Amazon.

It will also enable Lovefilm and Video Island, who are both backed by private equity groups, to generate marketing and operational savings.

Video Island currently has 200,000 subscribers to Love Film’s 120,000.

The two groups also run the online DVD rental operations of a number of other companies.

Video Island – whose main brand is Screen Select – operates Tesco, ITV, MSN and Easycinema’s operations; while Lovefilm handles Sainsbury’s, WH Smith, CD Wow and Film Four’s services.

‘Stronger company’

Revenues from the combined group totalled £25m last year, and both firms have been expanding into Europe.

Simon Calver, chief executive of Video Island, will take up the same role at the merged group.

“For three years both companies have done an excellent job changing the way DVDs are rented in the UK and Scandinavia, by providing customers with unparalleled value, choice and convenience,” he said.

“Together we will be a stronger company offering better features and service.”

Renting DVDs via the internet was first pioneered in the US by American market leader Netflix.

It is currently suing Blockbuster, claiming its rival copied its way of doing business.

Maiden’s ‘too expensive’ billboard deals scare off potential bidder

The Guardian

By Donovan Jones (seekingalpha)
  • Cautious start to takeover auction for advertiser

  • JCDecaux sees some of its contracts as uneconomic

Dan Milmo and Cosima Marriner (The Guardian)

The outdoor advertiser, Maiden Group, has received up to half a dozen takeover approaches, but one big rival has declined to bid, saying that its billboard contracts are “too expensive”.

Maiden, Britain’s fourth-largest outdoor advertiser, was put up for sale in December after breaching its banking covenants. The investment bank NM Rothschild, is running the auction and has received indicative bids from three advertisers, including Viacom Outdoor, a US-owned group, and Cemusa, a Spanish firm. It has also received approaches from two private equity players and an entrepreneur.

Ron Zeghibe, Maiden’s chief executive and largest shareholder, is not thought to have submitted a management buyout bid. Maiden’s management team owns more than 50% of the business. Shares in Maiden, which have put in a volatile performance this month, rose 14% to 68.5p yesterday, valuing the group at £36m.

However, one business widely expected to bid, the French outdoor advertiser JCDecaux, has not submitted an offer. Jean-François Decaux, co-chief executive of the group, said some contracts signed by Maiden last year had been renewed on uneconomical terms.

“The contracts they have renewed are far too expensive. We did not participate in the Rothschild process,” he said.

Last year, Maiden renewed a £450m contract to run poster campaigns in 17 railway stations, including King’s Cross and Liverpool Street in London. It also won full control of Network Rail’s roadside contract, covering advertising spaces on tracksides, station roads and bridges.

Some competitors were concerned about the cost of taking on these contracts in the event of a takeover. The standard outdoor advertising contract runs for up to 10 years and involves splitting the revenue with the site’s owner. This includes a minimum revenue guarantee and often features a sizeable upfront payment.

A number of significant outdoor contracts were put out to tender last year – including the Network Rail franchises – attracting interest from all the big players. The biggest UK contract this year covers London Underground. The incumbent, Viacom Outdoor, is thought to have lodged a bid for Maiden as an insurance policy in case it loses the Underground franchise.

Another potential Maiden suitor is Redbus Group, the company run by the young media entrepreneur Simon Franks. After making $34m (£19.2m) on the sale of his Redbus film distribution division to the US firm Lions Gate last year, Mr Franks’s main business is now Redbus Outdoor, which sells advertising space in supermarkets and on university campus billboards. Maiden’s railway and shopping-centre advertising assets are considered a good fit with Redbus Outdoor. Mr Franks confirmed yesterday that he was “actively monitoring” the Maiden situation, but had “absolutely decided not to bid” for it. However, Redbus is said to be interested in buying Maiden’s debt.

Some industry players are thought to be biding their time, waiting to see if Maiden’s financial condition deteriorates and if its contracts are retendered as a result, or if a fire sale is ordered.

Maiden has £39m of debt and owes trade creditors £20m. It has £9m cash on its balance sheet and faces a £2m legal bill following a recent high court ruling. However, the legal action is not thought to have material consequences for the group’s balance sheet. Maiden declined to comment yesterday.

Film deal with happy ending

Financial Times

Clay Harris (Mudlark)

Simon Franks went into the City, starting as a graduate trainee at JP Morgan, because that seemed to be the best way to raise the capital to achieve his goal of starting a business.

By the time he was 26 and a proprietary trader at Paribas, Franks owned his flat outright and had saved several hundred thousand pounds. Mortgaging the flat, raiding his savings and selling his car, Franks in 1998 started Redbus Film distribution, which is now a leading UK independent distributor as well as co-producer of films such as Bend it Like Beckham.

Redbus yesterday was sold for $41m (£23m) in cash and shares to Lions Gate Entertainment Toronto, the independent film producer and distributor, making him a multi-millionaire at 34.

The deal gives Lions Gate the ability to self-distribute its films in the UK. Franks, distribution president Zygi Kamasa and head of theatrical distribution Chris Bailey, will continue to run the UK operations. The sale does not include Redbus’s outdoor advertising business or its online video rental arm, Video Island.

Redbus Interhouse, the AIM-traded data storage and internet hosting company, is not related to Franks’ company apart from holding a license to use the name.

Franks saw Redbus’s success as a reflection of the application of business methods and a hint of that entrepreneurial talent that was latent in the City.

None of his team has a conventionally “creative” background. He said: “Every single person here came from banking, law, accountancy or something else in business.”

Franks said the sale of Redbus Film Distribution was a “happy and sad day – I love it like a baby.” But he could not resist a plug for Good Night, and Good Luck, directed by and starring George Clooney. “Go see it, it’s superb.”

DealMaker : US Studio Lions Gate Entertainment has bought Britain’s Redbus Film Distribution for $42m

Daily Telegraph

By Donovan Jones (seekingalpha)

US Studio Lions Gate Entertainment has bought Britain’s Redbus Film Distribution for $35m (£20m) in stock and cash

Dealmaker

US Studio Lions Gate Entertainment has bought Britain’s Redbus Film Distribution for $35m (£20m) in stock and cash. Lions Gate has also acquired Redbus’s library of distribution rights to more than 130 films including hits such as Bend it Like Beckham. Redbus chairman Simon Franks, a former JP Morgan Banker, founded the company in 1998. Redbus was advised on the deal by Allen & Co ‘s John Josephson and Omar Issani.

Original Article

Video Island buys DVDs365

mad.co.uk

Jim Butcher

Online DVD rental service Video Island, which merged with ScreenSelect last year, has acquired rival DVDs365 as it looks to expand further into the burgeoning market.

The company, which recently unveiled plans to invest 6 million in marketing over the next 12 months, will also own DVDs363’s sister brands mailbox Movies, QFlicks and Movietrak as part of the deal. Video Island said the acquisition would allow it to expand the reach of the business, which already supports the rental operations by Tesco, ITV, easyGroup and MSN.

Bill Dobbie, founder and managing director of DVDs365, will join Video Island as an advisor to the board. The move comes as Video Island announced it is planning to expand the number of titles it offers users, after securing an extra 5 million in funding from the venture debt provider EVP, bringing its total to 15 million. The firm currently offers more than 33,000 titles, more than any other service in Europe, as well as Radio Times’ film reviews and integrated movie news feeds.

Saul Klein, chief executive of Video Island, said of this latest deal: “Combining DVDs365’s expertise with Video Island’s unrivalled financial backing, innovative partnership strategy and position in the market, creates a uniquely strong independent player.”

Regarding the upcoming marketing drive, Klein said that the majority of the majority of spend would be used in conjunction with its partnerships, which include companies such as Boots, Currys and Times Newspapers. Last week the company struck deals with Mobix Interactive and IFILM in a bid to its expand its business beyond the postal service it currently operates to allow UK movie fans access to digital content and services.

Video Island raises extra £5m in backing

Screendaily

Author

Online DVD rental outfit Video Island has raised a further £5m in backing from EVP, Europe’s leading venture debt provider. The funding takes the total amount raised by Video Island to over £15m. EVP joins current equity investors Benchmark Capital, Cazenove Private Equity and Index Ventures.

The funding will be used to expand Video Island’s DVD library, to invest in current operations and will be earmarked for potential acquisition opportunities. Video Island CEO Saul Klein said: “Having already raised £10m, Video Island has always recognised that building a scaleable and substantial business in this sector is both extremely capital intensive and requires total operational focus combined with highly specialist expertise.”

Video Island, founded in September 2003, runs its own consumer brand ScreenSelect.co.uk as well as providing online DVD rental services for companies such as Tesco, MSN, ITV and easyGroup.

It claims a library of over 32,000 titles and makes nearly 1.5m shipments per month – the online equivalent of 150 high street stores. According to Screen Digest, the online video rental business has expanded dramatically in the last few months and is estimated to be on track to represent 15% of the total UK rental sector this year.